For more than a decade, Apple’s App Store worked as a closed loop: one storefront, one payment system, one commission rate. The European Union’s Digital Markets Act cut that loop open across 27 countries, and Apple has been rewriting its EU rulebook ever since.
The DMA is a regulation, not a lawsuit. It names a handful of “gatekeeper” platforms and hands them a list of obligations they must meet by a fixed date, with fines as the enforcement tool. Apple was designated in 2023, and the compliance deadline arrived in March 2024. What followed was a repeating pattern: Apple complied as narrowly as it could, the European Commission pushed back, and Apple revised its terms.

What the law actually demands of Apple
The obligations that matter most to the App Store are few. Apple has to allow rival app marketplaces on the iPhone, let developers use payment systems other than its own, and stop preventing developers from telling users about cheaper offers elsewhere. Browser choice screens and expanded access to certain hardware and software features for third parties round out the list. Each one targets a specific lever Apple used to keep users and developers inside its ecosystem.
Apple’s first answer came with iOS 17.4. Alternative marketplaces became possible in the EU, but the terms attached to them were new and unfamiliar. The centerpiece was the Core Technology Fee, a per-install charge on apps that crossed a large annual download threshold. Apple framed it as payment for the tools and intellectual property that developers rely on, whichever store they distribute through.
Developers heard something different. A per-install fee changes the math for any app that is free to download and earns little per user, because success itself becomes a cost. A small studio with a viral hit could owe Apple money precisely when its revenue per user was thinnest. That tension, between Apple’s claim to be paid for its platform and the regulator’s aim of lowering the cost of leaving it, drives nearly every dispute since.
The first wave of revisions did not end the argument. It moved it.

Fines, then a fee rewrite
In April 2025 the Commission fined Apple 500 million euros over its anti-steering rules, finding that the company had restricted developers from pointing customers to cheaper deals outside the App Store. Apple said it would appeal, and it also changed its EU terms. The revised structure replaced the Core Technology Fee with a percentage-based Core Technology Commission of 5 percent, alongside tiered store service fees and other charges layered on top.
The new model is easier to explain and probably easier to live with for apps with high install counts and little revenue. It is also more complicated, because a developer now has to add up several fees to learn what distribution actually costs. Whether the Commission treats that stack as compliance or as the old commission wearing new labels is the question still being argued.
Why the fee structure is the real battleground
It is tempting to read the DMA fight as a dispute about features: sideloading, browser choice, link-outs. It is really a dispute about who gets paid and for what. Apple’s argument is that its commission funds a platform that developers cannot replicate, covering security review, payment processing, distribution and the hardware customers already own. The regulator’s argument is that a commission is not a price in a competitive market when the platform controls the only door. Both claims have weight, which is why neither side can simply concede.
That is also why the rule changes keep arriving in installments. Each time Apple restructures a fee, the Commission has to judge whether the new number still amounts to a toll on rivals. A rule that says “allow alternatives” is easy to write and difficult to enforce, because an alternative that costs nearly as much as the incumbent is not much of an alternative. Regulators are being pulled into the business of reading pricing sheets, which is not work most competition authorities expected to do.
Apple has also drawn a line through its product roadmap. The company has held back certain features in the EU, citing the difficulty of meeting interoperability requirements without weakening privacy or security. Critics read that as pressure on regulators, with European users as the leverage. Apple’s defenders read it as a real engineering constraint. Both can be true at once, and neither has been settled in public, which is a problem in itself: a customer in Munich cannot tell whether a missing feature is a technical limitation or a negotiating position.

The effects are not confined to Europe. Japan has passed its own smartphone competition law, the UK has built a digital markets regime, and a US court order has already restricted Apple’s ability to charge commissions on certain link-outs to outside purchases. Apple now maintains different App Store rules by region, and each version is a test of how much it can concede in one market without weakening its position in another. For all that, the biggest unanswered question may be the dullest one. Alternative marketplaces exist on European iPhones, yet the App Store remains the default most people open without thinking, and a door that few walk through may not change much of anything.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the Digital Markets Act?
It is an EU regulation that sets obligations for large platforms designated as gatekeepers, including Apple. It targets practices that limit competition, such as restricting rival app stores and payment systems.
How has Apple changed the App Store in the EU?
Apple allowed alternative app marketplaces and payment options and revised its fee structure several times. It also changed its rules on how developers can steer users to offers outside the App Store.
Was Apple fined under the DMA?
Yes. In April 2025 the European Commission fined Apple 500 million euros over its anti-steering rules. Apple said it would appeal.









